Mayor Elmslie inquired whether anyone wished to speak to the proposed by-law.
Rebecca Schillemat, of the Peterborough and Kawartha Lakes Home Builders Association, spoke to the proposed By-Law to Impose Development Charges in the City of Kawartha Lakes. She acknowledged the work that the City of Kawartha Lakes has done to accommodate growth within the local area and noted that development charges are intended to pay for new infrastructure that is associated with growth. She outlined concern relating to the amount of the proposed increases in development charges and how the increases could have a negative affect on growth. She asked Council to consider phasing in the proposed increases.
Mayor Elmslie inquired whether anyone wished to speak to the proposed by-law.
Jeff Solly, of Tribute Communities, spoke to the proposed By-Law to Impose Development Charges in the City of Kawartha Lakes. He outlined concern with the amount of the proposed increase for development charges and noted that developers pass those charges onto homebuyers. He outlined that there is an affordability crisis in housing and expressed concern about the rate of increase. He recommended that council consider a phased implementation of the proposed development charges, a review of opportunities for discretionary exemptions for specified housing options, a review of the indexing of development charges, and that staff meet with interested developers to review the proposed development charges.
Mayor Elmslie inquired whether anyone wished to speak to the proposed by-law.
Peter Thoma, of urbanMetrics Inc., spoke to the proposed By-Law to Impose Development Charges in the City of Kawartha Lakes on behalf of Smartcentres Inc. He provided comments specific to non-residential development and raised concern about the proposed increase in development charges for such development. He also expressed concern about the removal of the discretionary exemption for the first 2500 sq. m. for commercial property. He stated that the proposed rate of increase will hurt the competitiveness of Kawartha Lakes as a business community. He further noted that the proposed increase will have consequences on development applications that are part way through the planning process, and that there is potential for the proposed increase to stall planned development. He asked Council to demonstrate restraint on the proposed development charges for non-residential lands while recognizing the timing and scale of the proposed increase and considering continuation of the commercial exemption. He asked that staff work with developers on creating a development charge structure that better balances growth and infrastructure needs.
Mayor Elmslie inquired whether anyone wished to speak to the proposed by-law.
Mark Wilson, of MVW Construction and Engineering, and of Wilson Developments, spoke to the proposed By-Law to Impose Development Charges in the City of Kawartha Lakes. He noted that he was a member of the Development Charges Task Force. He outlined that the housing market has experienced a notable slow down in both sales and housing starts, and he suggested that implementing development charges, as proposed, would undermine housing targets. He recommended that the implementation of the new development charges be delayed for twelve (12) months to provide an opportunity for the market to normalize and for newly arrived developers to gain their footing. He questioned whether or not the benefit from the new development charges will outweigh the risk. He outlined concern relating to the proposed increase for multi-residential development and questioned the data used to support the proposed increase for such development. He questioned whether area-specific development charges should be applied to infill development, and he spoke to the former development charges deferral policy. He recommended that adoption of a new development charges by-law reflect a measured approach and be carefully considered by staff and Council.
Mayor Elmslie inquired whether anyone else wished to speak to the proposed by-law. Mayor Emslie inquired for a second, third and final time whether anyone else wished to speak to the proposed by-law. There were no additional speakers.
Mayor Elmslie confirmed with the City Clerk that four pieces of correspondence had been submitted and circulated to Council relating to the proposed By-Law to Impose Development Charges in the City of Kawartha Lakes:
- Saverio Montemarano, Bromont Group of Companies, regarding Updated Development Charge Framework – Formal Comment Letter
- Peter Thoma, urbanMetrics Inc., regarding Proposed Development Charges Increases in Lindsay Urban Northwest Trunk Area, Non-Residential Rates
- Rebecca Schillemat, Peterborough & The Kawartha Home Builders Association, regarding City of Kawartha Lakes Development Charges
- Mark Wilson, MVW Construction and Engineering Inc., regarding Replacement of Development Charges By-Law 2019-184